Light/Breezes

Light/Breezes
SUNRISE AT DEATH VALLEY-Photo by Tom Cochrun

Thursday, August 6, 2020

difficult conversations


     There is a reach in this post that may move us to not entirely comfortable places, though the place we land is better, I think.
          As a result of an impending surgery last week, I wrote
"The Letter." 
      "The Letter" is that document you leave your loved ones, in case.  It is your last words. You say what should be said, you offer valedictory thoughts, you include details to help their moving on, managing the business of life, and you say good bye. It is grim work. The finality of your own mortal life is front and center. It gets your full attention. 
       When it is complete, it is a good thing. It offers a peace of mind, but it also generates a clarity. There is much in living that keeps us from a clear view of life. This task leads you to the essence.
       Writing "The Letter" is something I suggest, for people of a certain age, even if there are no surgical or medical riddles on the horizon. It is either the best, or worse, kind of what if contingency. 
       I think it helps draw you closer to your own life and to understandings. 
         
         There is another difficult conversation, a dialogue, I think the nation should begin. 
          Some will find even this suggestion hard to abide, but I've come to think it is our only hope. We should begin a 25 year process of a moderated public conversation about reckoning and reparations.
       A quarter of a century is a long process, but we are talking about origin issues. It is time to come clean, to acknowledge an unvarnished history of this nation and to dial it back to the time of sovereign residents, before European exploration and colonization.
      I imagine a national commission of sorts to preside over a calibrated and measured process that would have an impact on every aspect of our national life. 
      Education, law, economy, cultural mores, and human understanding would reap the benefits and consequences of a society having a discussion with itself in a very deliberate and intentional way. 
       25 years would allow for every historical accounting, gripe, grievance, tradition, presumption, mis understanding, dishonesty, and all the other effluence of our hundreds of years of becoming who we are, to be heard, seen, examined and understood. 


     The first years would be the fact finding and the sharing, putting all things on the table. Detailed and exhaustive, building what amounts to an honest revelation of all that we have been, done, in unescapable clarity.
     It would be the national discussion and the world would watch. I can see public hearings in every major city and state. The mechanics can be worked out so everyone could have their say.
      It's a broad idea, but it emerges from a life being spent as an observer, watcher, journalistically reflecting who we are.
       Maybe it is just my time on the watch, but race has been at the core our national existence and drama since I started reporting.

      1965 put me on the trail of the Ku Klux Klan, which became the rabbit hole of race in America that occupied much of my reporting life.
       The late David Brinkley and Senator Barry Goldwater  were two of the judges who awarded me a National Emmy Award for an investigation of the Klan. Brinkley called it  "one of television's finest hours."
       For almost 50 years I've watched and wondered why don't we try to fix this, why don't we just get painfully honest. 
     A 25 year national conversation will allow the honesty and  time to create a full account of history. With that achieved in the early decade, generations can then begin to mediate what to do about it, how to adapt, how to make amends. 
    By adding the element of Reparations, it will force this nation to come to a time of adjudication, judgement, and seeking meaning through recompense. It becomes an act of contrition, a national seeking of redemption. It will not be easy, nor should it be. It will force knowledge to become common and it will challenge our sense of justice, and it will force us to proceed with honesty, vigilance, and a new sense of who we are and who we will become. It will change the balance of things.


     Living through a pandemic has given all of us time to think. Our initial "We've Got This" attitude got tired as disruption continued. Flattening curves worked, until we rushed too fully back to a sense of normal. No one has lived through a challenge of this magnitude and we have come to realize we are indeed vulnerable and without a cure.
      That realization can work on a human psyche.
  
    The eastern slope of the high Serra has become a favorite place. The power and beauty of nature is awesome. But I also find great renewal in the vestige of the frontier life, thinking about the spirit of those hardy souls who made their way against it all.
    
    I felt an extra measure of that when I visited ancestral Scotland the brave.  Surviving challenges has pushed our advance and toughened us to living on this planet in the face of hostility.
          
     As California summer brings the thirsty brown and tan, I've been watching a few fighters.
     The thistle is the flower of Scotland. Here in California it is the bane of ranchers and gardeners, but I delight in their persistence.

    And after cousin of the wild thistle, our prolific artichoke bed passes its zenith, it offers a final salute of resilience and beauty.  
       So there you have it; challenging notions, hard suggestions for difficult conversations. If we are to see this republic survive, if the best of our aspirations are a noble human endeavor, we need to get tough and we need to be fully honest.

       Stay safe. Take care of each other.

       See you down the trail.

17 comments:

  1. I heard or read a suggestion recently that all of we of the senior set should begin a "When I Die" file. Not "If I Die" but "When I Die". It would set out all the financial information, passwords, wills, etc. etc. etc. are kept so that our survivors don't have such a difficult time sorting it all out. Sounds like a great idea to someone who is now an octogenarian. One of these days I'll begin.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Might give you fodder for a post. Stay well pal!

      Delete
  2. I just did a 400 word comment that deleted it'self at the end. will try again

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mike, Sorry about the technical issue. Always appreciate what you have to say.

      Delete
  3. Am glad your letter was not needed-- lets keep it that way for as long as possible :) Your family needs you-- and we need your words of history and hope -- and more of those spectacular photographs! Be well my friend--

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jill, I appreciate your thoughts and encouragement. Everything looks good and so now I await being able to get back to exercise and a return to tennis. You stay well too, you have always been a beam of sunshine.

      Delete
  4. Interesting "two-headed" post. Hope you did (or will) come out of your surgery fit as a Stradivarius. Three years ago I had a quadruple bypass, went into it with a "well isn't this interesting" attitude, came out fine, if a bit wobbly for awhile. Still haven't done what I should do about records; which I will do soon as I clean up my home office and garage.
    Regarding the reparations question, my thoughts fall on both sides of it. How do you make repayment for two+ centuries of slavery and mistreatment? No way to "repair" that. And the only "fair" way to correct for stolen land is to give it back. I don't see current Americans doing that, even with 25 years of discussion. However, I think the discussions would be a good thing, even a necessary thing, though it might go well beyond talk. Do you see it as continuing for that long without a significant tangible pay-off?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Steve. The tennis game is taking a hit, it will be another 5 weeks before I can get back to being active. I'm sure my body will appreciate the rest, but my timing and "skills" are going to need work. Oh well, we old jocks always need a new project.
      As for your points-you raise good questions. I'm assuming that over the course of the national hearings and deliberations, those generations 20 years hence will be tasked with determining the answers. To do so will be part of establishing a new sense of nationhood. How they define reparations, after the data is on the table, is part of the process.

      Delete
  5. Thanks Tom. Always look forward to another edition of Light Breezes.

    Maybe sometime you can take some photos of Yosemight park for us?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mike-
      I will look through the archives and try to pull some Yosemite shots. Once travel is acceptable and you are comfortable, you should plan a journey. I think it is your kind of place. Be well.

      Delete
  6. I'm in my third week of recovery from spine surgery. It has been rough. I need to give more thought to "that letter" or more specifically, that file of where and how and what would be left behind.
    But your other topic, full revelation and reparations for our nation's history really has me thinking. My first response, unfortunately, is "you can't handle the truth". But as the BLM movement persists, maybe there is hope. Having a humanitarian in the White House would help.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Linda, wishing you well in your recovery.
    I'm hopeful that a 25 year frame on the process would allow for a kind of compression chamber to absorb the emotion and to permit the truth to emerge and then in turn guide all efforts at resolution. Idealistic no doubt, but who are we, if not aspirational?
    I hope you begin to feel better.

    ReplyDelete
  8. From what you state here, it reads to me that things are on a better path. If I am reading it correctly, I am very glad. I value you and your words.

    PipeTobacco

    ReplyDelete
  9. Tom:

    If I misread.... thinking your surgery had either occurred and was successful, or was deemed not necessary.... I apologize.

    In my *thinking* that everything sounded “ok” now.... that is where my “better path” comment originated. But, regardless... I still want you to know I value you and your words here.

    PipeTobacco

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the kind words and note. I am on the path to recovery and looking forward to when I can be cleared to resume regular exercise and tennis.

      Delete